Goretex Outdoor Research Seattle Sombrero like this blue one (I have 3 of them – lost and replaced the first one, then found #1 again and got #3 as a gift) and an Outback Trading crushable oilskin Madison River are my two favorite paddling hat styles. Both have wide stiff brims and protect from sun and rain.
For punkie, biting gnat and black fly season I have an older Ex Officio boonie style with a full drop-down micromesh headnet built into a pocket in the crown.
I recently saw some really cheap Tilleys in Costco which sent me down a rabbit hole - it looks like many Tilley hats are now made in China.
I have several Outdoor Research hats, and fully agree the Seattle Sombrero is an excellent piece of gear for rainy days. The OR sun hats have some good features (comfortable, light, packable, quick-drying), but being made of thin/light material, I find they loose their shape after only a few seasons of hard use. Still, fair value I suppose.
I just ordered the Lonix Ranger, based on a recommendation from myccr (and having had one many years ago), and am optimistic the Lonix will be as good or better than the Tilley.
I lucked out at the closeout store again. They had Columbia “Bell Ranch Boonies” for $5 in a good khaki color, and all hats were another 50% off. I couldn’t find any info online for the Bell Ranch hat, but it looks identical to the Bora Bora. Perhaps it was a Bora Bora given an exclusive name for a specific retailer.
As others have reported, the brim on the Bora Bora is too floppy for windy conditions, but its a very comfortable ventilated hat for low-wind kayak days, hiking, mowing, etc. I bought a bunch at that price.
The original, Tilley T3 Cotton Duck hat. It has served me well over many years, in any condition I have been in. Wouldn’t be without it. When I need more side sun protection, I turn to a Buff.
For hot, sunny days I use an old Sequel hat. I think it was called the Desert Rhat. It’s the kind that looks like a baseball cap with a large brim and a cape.
For warm but not sunny outings, I’ll sometimes use a baseball style cap.
I’m on my 2nd Tilley which replaced the first that the sun had basically fried.
I also have a Seattle Sombrero but seldom wear it because it’s usually too hot here.
You probably remember the lively discussions, aka pissing contests, regarding Tilly hats. They had the only size that fit my big head comfortably. I wish I had discovered them years before.
My dermatologist doesn’t regret my late discovery.
And it just so happens I was just at my dermatologist for a checkup last week. When he looked at my bald head, he said your head looks really good, do you wear a hat?
Many hats will protect you from the sun, of course. But my Tilley does so many other things so well, I have never found a hat as good for what I want a hat to do. A good fit is important. Good retention straps are important as well, for me, never found a better system for retention. It even floats, this I know from experience, smile. That bit of padding comes in handy at times too. Takes a licking and keeps on ticking.