Hello.
I’ve been browsing this forum for a while now but this is my first time posting. I’m looking for some general advice that might be able to help others in the future too, as well as any input anyone can offer for my specific situation.
TLDR: Newbie trying to understand and figure out if it’s worth saving and waiting to try to get a higher-end rec kayak or if a cheaper one would actually be noticeably different. With my current lifestyle, I can’t imagine ever getting to a point of using the kayak for more than a couple hours at a time on totally flat, calm, slow water. I waffle back and forth between the “buy the best kayak you can afford” and the “any kayak that gets you on the water is best” mentalities. Trying to figure out where the balance point is between them.
The weather is cooling down a lot where I live now and the season is probably close to over. There’s a chance we’ll get snow before the end of this month. I’m watching for a good deal on a used kayak this fall/winter or debating if I should save up and try to buy in the spring instead. But buying used means I can’t try before I buy, though even if I could I’m not sure I know enough to be able to tell the difference between a good and bad kayak.
I’ve rented a kayak a number times over the last decade and I always really enjoy it and I’m finally considering buying something of my own. (A friend bought a rec kayak this year, so I finally have someone I could go with. They bought a Pelican Escape 120 rec kayak, so not a high end one by any means.) I’m the type of person that likes to do tons of research and try to learn about all the different options when I’m shopping for something so I’ve been reading forums, reviews, manufacturer websites, etc. and I’m checking local listings of used kayaks pretty much daily in hopes of maybe finding a good deal. (There’s not a lot where I live, and I think this is an extra hard year to be looking.)
I’ve looked at all kinds of kayak specs and models that look really nice but I’m struggling to figure out, as the topic suggests, the balance between my wants and what I really need for my use.
I live in Western Canada but I’m about a two-day drive from the coast, so no coastal or ocean kayaking. The only water I would ever be on are lakes (NOT any of the Great Lakes or anything huge like that) and small, not very fast-moving creeks/rivers. I have absolutely no interest in any kind of rapids or anything like that. I’m a slow, flat water person and I can’t imagine a situation where I would be out of swimming distance from shore. (And I’m adamant about wear a PFD at all times on any kind of watercraft.)
I also don’t think I’ll ever be on the water for more than 3 or 4 hours at a time at the absolute max. More realistically, probably only one or two hours at a stretch usually. No camping, or even full days gear-hauling or anything like that. Also not likely to do any fishing, though it’s possible my spouse might be interested in that.
I’ve read a lot about how longer kayaks track straighter and move faster than shorter ones for instance. There are so many “Oh, that sounds like the better thing to aim for” but most of the kayaks that I’m finding have good reviews and meet some of these specs are like $1200+ new, and don’t seem to be very common in my area, especially used.
At the end of the day, I don’t know if it makes sense for me to be that picky though, given what my actual use is likely to be. For someone that’s only going to be out for an hour or two at a time, on flat water, is a 12’ kayak really noticeably different from a 10’?
A Riot Quest 10HV was recently listed used for $300, and a 2014 Pungo 100 was $650. Both seem like reasonable prices but I didn’t even consider them because they were “only 10’ kayaks and I think I should probably get at least a 12’ " but I’m wondering if, given my realistic use, I’m being ridiculous?? (I’m about 5’7” and 180-ish lbs too by the way.)
I’ve seen a lot of people say to stay away from cheaper brands like Pelican, but are the higher end of their line of kayaks at all decent? They seem to have bought and rebranded the Elie kayaks a couple years ago. Are ALL Pelican kayaks bad? Again, given only flat, calm, slow water? Where I live they’re certainly a lot more common than the more reputable brands like Eddyline, Wilderness Systems, Old Town, Perception, Dagger, etc.